Back to top

Taking the Land to Make the City

Taking the Land to Make the City
A Bicoastal History of North America

The award-winning historian Mary P. Ryan offers a new vision of early American history that focuses on the contributions of cities and of West Coast Hispanic culture to the forging of an American system of democracy and capitalism.

Series: Lateral Exchanges

March 2019
Add to cart
448 pages | 6 x 9 | 16 color and 60 b&w photos |

The history of the United States is often told as a movement westward, beginning at the Atlantic coast and following farmers across the continent. But cities played an equally important role in the country’s formation. Towns sprung up along the Pacific as well as the Atlantic, as Spaniards and Englishmen took Indian land and converted it into private property. In this reworking of early American history, Mary P. Ryan shows how cities—specifically San Francisco and Baltimore—were essential parties to the creation of the republics of the United States and Mexico.

Baltimore and San Francisco share common roots as early trading centers whose coastal locations immersed them in an international circulation of goods and ideas. Ryan traces their beginnings back to the first human habitation of each area, showing how the juggernaut toward capitalism and nation-building could not commence until Europeans had taken the land for city building. She then recounts how Mexican ayuntamientos and Anglo American city councils pioneered a prescient form of municipal sovereignty that served as both a crucible for democracy and a handmaid of capitalism. Moving into the nineteenth century, Ryan shows how the citizens of Baltimore and San Francisco molded landscape forms associated with the modern city: the gridded downtown, rudimentary streetcar suburbs, and outlying great parks. This history culminates in the era of the Civil War when the economic engines of cities helped forge the East and the West into one nation.

  • Introduction
  • Part I. Taking the Land
    • Chapter 1. Before the Land Was Taken
    • Chapter 2. The British and the Americans Take the Chesapeake
    • Chapter 3. The Land of San Francisco Bay: Cleared But Not Taken
  • Part II. Making the Municipality: The City and the Pueblo
    • Chapter 4. Erecting Baltimore into a City: Democracy as Urban Space, 1796–1819
    • Chapter 5. Shaping the Spaces of California: Ranchos, Plazas, and Pueblos, 1821–1846
  • Part III. Making the Modern Capitalist City
    • Chapter 6. Making Baltimore a Modern City, 1828–1854
    • Chapter 7. The Capitalist “Pueblo”: Selling San Francisco, 1847–1856
  • Part IV. These United Cities
    • Chapter 8. Baltimore, San Francisco, and the Civil War
  • Epilogue
  • Acknowledgments
  • Notes
  • Index

Berkeley, California

A noted historian who has won the Bancroft Prize and the Berkshire Prize, Ryan is the author of several books, including Cradle of the Middle Class: The Family in Oneida County, New York, 1790–1865; Civic Wars: Democracy and Public Life in the American City during the Nineteenth Century; and Mysteries of Sex: Tracing Women and Men through American History. She is an emeritus professor of history at the John Hopkins University and the University of California, Berkeley.


“Ryan casts cities as evolving organisms, born of material environmental conditions; political, social, and commercial relations; and ideas about how to organize life…With several maps to provide robust detail, Ryan argues that as denizens of Baltimore and San Francisco were constructing cities, they were also constructing a new world of commerce and politics.”

“Throughout this very engaging and important book, [Ryan] notes how the organizing of the land nurtured democracy…, enabled commercial and then industrial capitalism to take hold, and contributed to the formation of a bicoastal nation independent of foreign control.”
Journal of Urban History

“[A] conceptually ambitious history...With remarkable attention to detail, Ryan weaves deftly between the fields of political geography, vernacular architecture, and urban history to make the persuasive case that cities were incubators of American democracy, American capitalism, and the American nation itself...Taking the Land to Make the City is an elegant portrait of early Baltimore and San Francisco that is as enjoyable as it is insightful. It offers a convincing case for the centrality of urban history to the metanarratives of early US history and deserves to be widely read.”
H-Net Reviews

“Ryan generously shares her deep knowledge of the emergence of Baltimore and San Francisco, two storied cities she has studied long and well...[Taking the Land to Make the City] is deeply informed, clearly written, and engagingly told.”
American Historical Review

“[Taking the Land to Make the City] crafts a persuasive tale of the landscapes and polities of Baltimore and San Francisco as similarly mediating between physical and philosophical poles of government power, racial and socio-economic segregation, and territorial conquest...[Taking the Land to Make the City] both showcases a new methodology for conceptualizing American history and proclaims the importance of both cities in asserting distinct approaches to settlement, capitalism, and urban form that negotiated between national extremes.”
Western Historical Quarterly

“[Taking the Land to Make the City] is a masterful ‘how to’ for those embarking on writing comparative urban histories that link archival methods with the contextual questions that arise from viewing cities’ unique spatial histories in relation to one another...By detailing Baltimore and San Francisco’s history from the engineering of soil to the sale of waterfront property, Taking the Land to Make the City explicates how there could have been, and might still be, another urban future on the horizon.”
Planning Perspectives

“[Ryan's] bicoastal comparison dislodges the Atlantic supremacy of early American history...Ryan’s attention to the spatial production of representative democracy and municipal capitalism in cities builds on her pathbreaking work on the evolution of early American capitalism and democracy in Cradle of the Middle Class (1981) and Women in Public: Between Banners and Ballots (1990). In Taking the Land, cities were not simply sites of experimentation, but agents in producing a public—a public sphere, public markets, public parks, plazas and monuments, and a public consciousness.”
Reviews in American History

Taking the Land to Make the City is an imaginatively conceived and elegantly written account of antebellum city building in San Francisco and Baltimore. It draws upon recent currents in national and environmental history to open new vistas for urban history...Ryan’s focus on city building in San Francisco and Baltimore presents a fascinating transnational story that contrasts the forms of two competing colonial projects, the English in Baltimore and the Spanish and Mexicans in San Francisco.”
Journal of American History

“[A] deeply researched history of Baltimore and San Francisco...[Ryan's] attention to Native American settlements and land use is an important corrective to urban and planning histories, which often start with European ideas about and plans for cities in the Americas.”
Journal of the Civil War Era

“This brilliant and provocative book offers both a deeply satisfying comparative history of early Baltimore and San Francisco and a model for reimagining the long sweep of US history. Asking how native land became urban real estate in the British and Spanish Americas, Ryan reveals the contradictory origins of a revolutionary and democratic bicoastal political culture. As locals scrambled to make San Francisco and Baltimore, these cities’ distinctive sovereignties were brought closer together on the eve of the Civil War by a maturing capitalist infrastructure. The nation ruptured along a North-South axis, but Ryan’s bicoastal urban history uniquely shows why the United States was ultimately able to rebuild.”
Alison Isenberg, Princeton University, author of Designing San Francisco: Art, Land, and Urban Renewal in the City by the Bay

“San Francisco and Baltimore became American cities simultaneously, but only a scholar of Mary Ryan’s creativity could put these stories together so insightfully. Drawing connections that no other historian has seen, Ryan has written a book full of surprises for even the most devoted students of urban history. Unsparing in its attention to colonialism and capitalism as shapers of American civic culture, Taking the Land to Make the City is also an urgent reminder that cities have been—and will again be—our best hope for forging an inclusive and meaningful democracy.”
Seth Rockman, Brown University, author of Scraping By: Wage Labor, Slavery, and Survival in Early Baltimore


Available for Kindle
Available on Google Play
Available on Kobo
Available for Nook
Available on the Apple Store

This book may also be available on the following library platforms; check with your local library:
3M Cloud Library/bibliotheca