Taylor’s study critically compares the manpower and revenues of Republican Rome with those of Carthage and the Antigonid, Seleucid and Ptolemaic kingdoms. In a challenge to 'military tributary' grand theory, he argues that it was not its manpower or revenues in themselves that made Rome so powerful but its political and social structures.
~Dominic Rathbone
Soldiers and Silver develops a novel approach, as Taylor argues that the rise of Rome cannot be fully understood unless its opponents' manpower and resources are also taken into account.
~Toni Ñaco del Hoyo
The great strength of this book is that it is comparative; all too often studies probing Roman victory focus too much on Rome and consequently miss things about Rome’s rivals...Taylor considers the systems of all of the major players in the Mediterranean state system...and that fact alone puts this study head and shoulders above similar older efforts.
~A Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry
An interesting read…Taylor has succeeded at clarifying an often-unclear topic with some fine scholarship.
~Ancient World Magazine
This book will be of interest to anyone with a serious interest in the mechanics of ancient Roman and Hellenistic warfare. Its emphasis on the interplay between recruitment and finance – an aspect that has only recently received more scholarly attention – shows the importance of a solid financial structure behind any military venture.
~Ancient Warfare
Soldiers & Silver is an important and valuable study for ancient military historians...Soldiers & Silver provides the basis for renewed debate among specialists about ancient military manpower, finance, and the relationship between war and the state...Taylor’s work is a good candidate for a graduate course and a valuable addition to the military history of the Roman republican and Hellenistic periods.
~Journal of Military History
This book represents a rare and impressive breadth of research across the ancient Mediterranean and sheds new light on a critical period in Western history. Its conclusions will be fundamental to future study of an age-old but still highly relevant area of enquiry.
~Journal of Roman Studies
Soldiers and Silver is a compelling and insightful exploration of the 'grand game of Mediterranean geopolitics' (3) during a portion of the Roman Republican period (509–27 BCE)...An invaluable overview of inter-Mediterranean conflicts and the military economy in this period....Soldiers and Silver will no doubt become a standard 'go-to' text for military historians regarding economic aspects of the Roman conquests of the Republican era.
~Michigan War Studies Review
[A] tightly written monograph...Taylor argues that Romans won ultimately because they were able to muster a larger fighting force. The narrative includes a number of fresh and more nuanced thoughts about how Romans paid for and deployed their numerical advantage...The author’s excellent mind for military strategy and tactics is on display throughout...Taylor’s sturdy account is welcome reading.
~American Historical Review
